One Reason Why "Sin City" is One of My Ten Favorite Movies

Absolute respect for and faithfulness to the source material, the rewards of which are evident even to even those unfamiliar with the original stuff.

Tacky much, IMDB review summaries?

Yikes:

If the public reacts to We Are Marshall (starring Matthew McConaughey and Matthew Fox) the way many critics have, the film will come crashing down like the plane that carried 75 Marshall University players to their deaths in 1970.